Welcome to Johnny's New York Style Pizza
Johnny's New York Style Pizza, located in Athens, GA, offers a pizza experience brimming with authentic New York flavors. Known for its warm and inviting atmosphere, the restaurant complements delightful dishes like their acclaimed White Pizza and crispy garlic knots with marinara. Diners rave about the friendly staff, who enhance the experience with their upbeat service. The menu also features Parmigiana subs and a Kids Menu, catering to all ages. With a commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, Johnny's stands out as a must-visit for pizza lovers seeking a hearty, delicious meal that feels like a slice of home.
-
1040 Gaines School Rd Suite 219, Athens, GA 30605, United States1040 Gaines School Rd Suite 219, Athens, GA 30605, United States Hotline: +1 706-354-1515
Welcome to Johnny's New York Style Pizza, a culinary gem nestled in Athens, Georgia, at 1040 Gaines School Rd Suite 219. This vibrant pizzeria captures the essence of New York’s iconic slice, bringing a taste of the Big Apple right to the heart of the South.
At Johnny's, each pizza is crafted with passion and an eye for detail, featuring specialty pies that are nothing short of extraordinary. Among the highlights, the Johnny's White stands out—a delightful blend of ricotta, mozzarella, provolone, and parmesan cheeses, infused with garlic for a creamy and flavorful experience. If you're a cheese lover, the Quattro Formaggio is unmissable, harmoniously combining mozzarella, asiago, provolone, and parmesan for a rich and indulgent bite.
For a fresher take, the Margherita pizza tops a light sauce with diced tomatoes, fresh basil, and mozzarella, offering a refreshing balance perfect for a summer evening. The Veggie Deluxe is another standout, packed with onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and more for those seeking a hearty plant-filled option.
But Johnny’s is not just about pizzas; their selection of oven-baked subs and wraps is equally impressive. The Johnny's Special Sub is a flavor-packed delight, filled with ham, salami, capicolla, and a medley of fresh toppings, while the Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap is a go-to for those craving a quick yet fulfilling meal.
According to customer experiences, the atmosphere here is as warm as the pizza, with reviews like one from Alysa Rhyne highlighting the "amazing" White pizza and vibrant, welcoming staff. Tyler Rawlings shared a story of excellent service even amid a mix-up, showcasing the restaurant's commitment to customer satisfaction.
Don’t skip the garlic knots or mild wings as appetizers; patrons rave about how perfectly crispy the wings are, lightly tossed in sauce without overwhelming the dish. Misty Elkins emphasized the restaurant's cleanliness and the deliciousness of every item they ordered, a testament to Johnny’s commitment to quality flavors and a pleasant dining experience.
With friendly service, a diverse menu, and a space that invites conversation and enjoyment, Johnny's New York Style Pizza is a must-visit destination for pizza lovers in Athens. Come for the delicious food and stick around for the great atmosphere—your taste buds will thank you!
Recommended by a fellow Georgian that this was the best pizza in town. The White pizza was AMAZING. Employees are upbeat and make you feel welcome.
Had a great first experience. The staff was very helpful and engaging. I placed an online take-out order and arrived when I requested to have my pizza ready. Unfortunately, the order was never received received. The staff kindly comp'd my order for the inconvenience. I did have to wait, but did not mind as the atmosphere is inviting and entertaining. As for the pizza, let's just say I cannot wait to go back! It was one of the best if not the best I have had in Athens. Also, despite the order not going through, the app is very easy and convenient to use and did not have any problems ordering.
Place is spot on. So far best pizza in Athens. Definitely going back.great service..
My Family and I ate here today for the first time. Friendly staff and clean restaurant. All the food we had ordered was super delicious! Garlic knots with marinara, Greek salad, and mild wings for appetizer. The wings are crispy and we really like how they weren't drowning in the sauce. It was just right. The white pizza is so good! I highly recommend this restaurant!
Great food, wonderful service and I will be happy to come again.
Glad to be able to enjoy calzone again. Always outstanding . Enjoyed again. Outstanding as always. Outstanding calzones. Pizza excellent also. Servers very friendly. Try the 10 pound calzone challenge if you dare.
Just moved to Athens after being displaced by Hurricane Helene. I am trying to navigate the food scene and truly feel that I have found a place that I will continue to visit. Food was fresh, tasty, and hot. Customer service was outstanding as they should empathy for my displacement but welcomed me to the area. Truly refreshing in the midst of lifestyle changes. Definitely found my comfort food.
Cozy atmosphere. Madison provides great service and follow-up throughout the meal. Great pizza. Pizza by the slice slices are huge.